[QUESTION] Rule 1; part 7

[TaaviLaudur]

The rule from F1 window: "Killing any player by parking on them, or repetitively ramming them with your vehicle".

So we have following situation: https://streamable.com/aoydov

This got reported ingame and got the following answer by Daryl: "The rule is "killing someone by repetitively ramming them", the second rule relevant would be park arresting, which didn't happen."
So that isnt a rulebreak and no punishment was given to that officer.

I asked a question ingame via /ask about park arresting and got the following answer from SNome: "Ramming multiple times in order to stun lock them is not allowed.

From my prespective the criminal was clearly in a stunlock via ramming.
My question is the following. Who's word should be considered in this situation?
Is this a rulebreak or not?

Edit: If the criminal would of been arrested instead of killed at that situation, would it be a rulebreak?

[Kilios]

@sila

When i ram people with the car i allways give them a chance to get up, i give around 5 secounds for them, that means they have time to get up and take their gun.

[Arkantos]

Here is the topic I am looking for (Video also has nice DM)

[Stone]

Honestly, I don't see what the big deal with ramming a suspect to give a chance for your squad mates to get out of the car and arrest. It's a strategic maneuver. Most of the times wanted suspects like to throw grenades at the cars before the cops are even out and that's the best way for them to kill you off. If it's when you do it in a repetitive manner then , yes I understand. But I'll admit, when a criminal is on foot , I usually ram them, accelerate a little further and let my squad mates out to avoid grenades.

[alius]

@SAFP-Stoner said in [QUESTION] Rule 1; part 7:

Honestly, I don't see what the big deal with ramming a suspect to give a chance for your squad mates to get out of the car and arrest. It's a strategic maneuver. Most of the times wanted suspects like to throw grenades at the cars before the cops are even out and that's the best way for them to kill you off. If it's when you do it in a repetitive manner then , yes I understand. But I'll admit, when a criminal is on foot , I usually ram them, accelerate a little further and let my squad mates out to avoid grenades.

All you guys do is /cargrab onto Water Tank or the SUV which you can all shoot from /cargrab for fuck all reason, and you when you ungrab you can move instantly without having to do any anim like the driver. Shooting from grabbing makes zero sense when you have 6 people grabbed shooting at you with M4 lmfao.

[Stone]

I don't even use the tank or SUV . But, yes. that happens. What does that have to do with the ramming?

[Daryl]

Locking this, will revert back with an answer in a day or so, you're going off top from the original query now.

[Daryl]

I can only apologise for the time taken for a response. After a clan discussion and vote the rule has been changed to be far less ambiguous.

https://saesrpg.uk/topic/8193/saes-rpg-rules-regulations/4

Thanks for the suggestion.